Saturday, 28 April 2012

Populism. The new way to decide planning applications?

As many of the more observant will have noticed, on 3rd May it is time once again for that one quarter of the electorate that can be bothered to visit their local school and mark a cross next to a name that sounds vaguely familiar.

Yes, it's local election time.  That period every four years when environmentally responsible political parties litter our doorsteps with unwanted flyers festooned with cut and pasted pledges, cheesy photographs and the occasional dubious graph to show just how bad 'the other lot' are.

It is pretty usual at this time in the electoral cycle for local councillors to re-appear into view and to shout from the rooftops their commitment to whatever the 'popular view' may be on matters affecting their constituents.  This year however populism is more rife than ever.   In many parts of the country we are expecting major upheavals of local government, with many key councils likely to change political colour or enter into cross party alliances.  The stakes are particularly high - and all this is happening in the brave new world of localism.

This is not good news for planning decision making.  Planning committees in March and April have in many places become opportunities to grandstand. Woe betide the applicant with a proposal that has a strong planning merit but a degree of local opposition - in this period, the chances of approval are likely to be seriously harmed.

 Too often, it seems, decisions are being made at this time in the electoral cycle on grounds of political short term expediency rather than planning merit.  

It seems perverse that while the rules of purdah (Sorry, politically correct WG, rules of the pre- election period) mean that politically sensitive announcements can't be made in the period leading up to the elections, this doesn't stop the most politically sensitive decisions being made in the same period in the name of local votes.

We can't halt the planning process for several months every few years.  That would be impractical.  There is however surely scope to find a way to filter out the applications at risk from political manipulation?

The trouble is, I am not sure that politicians would want that.  These 'final' decisions of an administration are much like presidential pardons - often unpalatable but the price we have to pay for our system of democracy.  As Winston Churchill once put it, "democracy is the worst form of government except for all the others that have been tried."



Tuesday, 3 April 2012

Pasty tax - A half baked idea for our high streets?


Three months after Mary Portas’ high profile review, the UK Government has dealt a hammer blow to one of the current cornerstones of our beloved high streets. The timing of this blow is even more unfortunate when you consider the UK’s town centres currently have the highest average vacancy rates since records began (now 14.6%).

Bakeries, and in particular the rise of bakery chain Greggs, have been one of the few, if not only, high street success stories of recent years. The introduction of a 20% levy on some items in a sector that operates on tight profit margins will lead to some very difficult decisions for bakers up and down the country. If operations carry on in their current format, how and when to charge is the first obvious and well-documented grey area. If customers cannot stomach the price increase (sorry), bakeries may have to take a view on what temperature to serve their products at. In the past one would have said ‘woe betide anyone who serves me a cold sausage roll’. But at a time when everybody is watching every penny, we would probably prefer that to paying 20% more or anyone losing their job.

Unfortunately, this VAT change could mean another unwanted record in terms of average vacancy rates on our high streets, as bakers and your average blue-collar customer struggle to absorb the cost overnight.

The last thing our high streets need now is a VAT attack. Add to this the fact some big high street names, such as Game and Peacocks, are in administration and hanging on by a thread and you could be forgiven for feeling a tad cynical about Friday’s announcement that the Government will be adopting “virtually all” of Portas’ 28 recommendations (Taxing bakeries was not one of them). This will be of no comfort to high street bakeries. 

There is an argument that other "take aways" are taxed in this way and this is just levelling the playing field.  Bakeries are however an A1 use, one that we try to focus in our high streets and not one that we try and tuck away in the back streets.  While the focus has been on Greggs, there are still many independent pasty shops who do not have the ability to cut costs in the way that larger companies do and will be hit hard by this.

In land use terms this will simply increase the number of voids in our principal shopping areas.  Somewhat of a half-baked idea, then....