The pro-development approach of the NPPF has
helped to bring about rapid new growth in housing development in some parts of
England. This resurgence is involving
sites, more often than not, in locations that are not allocated for housing, or
indeed any development.
This can, in some places, put new pressures
on infrastructure and the planning system has its ways and means, through CIL
(for the moment!) and Section 106 agreements, to address these impacts.
One area of infrastructure untouched by
such measures, however, is the local sewage network.
Section 106 of the Water Industry Act 1991
places a duty on water authorities to accept new connections to their sewage
systems. Their ability to reject such
connections is limited to very specific circumstances, such as where the
connecting pipe does not meet the requisite standards.
The practical effect of this is therefore
that, on payment of a relatively low fixed fee, a developer may connect to a
mains sewer regardless of whether the sewer system has the capacity to
accommodate the additional flows.
The water authority therefore has no means
of stopping the system becoming overloaded.
Of course, if it does get overloaded and foul water escapes from the
sewage system, the water authority is liable of a criminal offence under Section
85 of the 1991 Act and European law.
The duty to make sure that the system can
cope with the demands placed upon it falls squarely on the water authority.
Section 94 of the 1991 Act requires water
authorities to provide, improve and extend the system of public sewers so as to
ensure that the area is effectually drained.
Unless drainage works are required to serve
a single development alone (rather than, say, improvement of existing mains
infrastructure) the cost of such improvement works falls on the water authority
itself.
Given that this almost certainly involves
new infrastructure and considerable spending, forward planning of requirements
is essential.
In this regard, the development plan
identifies anticipated housing growth and locations and the SHLAA will give
some clear indication of likely housing pressures for the future. We are told that the water authorities take
all of these into account in their infrastructure plans - so if housing is in
the planning pipeline, then there should be the pipelines to accommodate it.
The housing growth that we are seeing at
the moment is however, to a significant extent, not in locations anticipated by
development plans and so in many places the infrastructure plans are inadequate
or out of sync with actual development.
Insofar as the water authorities have no
real powers themselves to stop or delay development, the planning system has,
in some locations, stepped in to assist.
This is typically done through Grampian conditions that require there to
be sewage capacity to be demonstrated before new houses are occupied.
Eminently sensible, one might say. Except of course that the effect of such a
condition is in all too many cases, a ransom position in the favour of the
water authority.
They are described as “authorities” but the
reality is of course that they are private companies with a duty to make
profits for their own shareholders. They
have no real interest in delivering new housing or the jobs that it brings or
any particular desire to be forced into building new, un-forecast sewage
infrastructure that will impact on forecast profit levels. They cannot be criticised for that – it is
the logical effect of their privatisation all those years ago.
What is more concerning is that the water
authorities have become increasingly aware of the position of power they hold
in respect of large planning applications and seem to be seeing this as a
lucrative new revenue stream.
Knowing that a Grampian condition is a real
problem for housing developers, most water authorities now charge fees of
several hundred pounds for telling you what existing capacity levels are
at. One would really have thought they would
have such data at the tips of their fingers.
If that is not bad enough, if it is
determined that there is a shortfall in capacity, they will charge many
thousands of pounds to scope out what works are required to address it.
In such cases the water authorities know
that developers won´t and can´t just take a Grampian condition and sit and wait
for them to undertake the necessary improvements to the sewage system. Instead, a simple choice is presented – the developer
pays to get the improvements early, or the development can´t go ahead.
At no stage does the duty under Section 94
of the Act, for the water authorities themselves to meet the local drainage
needs, seem to come into play.
To some, this is a pragmatic way of
bringing forward new infrastructure at the cost of those who will benefit from
it. To others, it looks like pure and
simple cash generation by greedy water companies.
Whatever your point of view, this
disconnect between development aspirations and certainty of mains sewage infrastructure
presents a major blockage to the actual delivery of much needed housing.
Some local planning authorities have shown
their mettle by refusing to impose conditions on new development requiring
sewage capacity to be demonstrated.
The
stark choice for the water authority in such circumstances is to bring forward
the necessary improvements or face overflow problems and the fines that will
result. However, that local authorities
should have to risk sewage overflow to get the water authorities to act is not
exactly a vote winner with the electorate.
It is clear that government has to take a
look at this and find a more workable, efficient and cost effective means of
delivering the sewage infrastructure required for this new wave of development
that it is encouraging. Sewage is not
something that one can brush under the carpet, Mr Pickles.