When PPS4 was issued in 2009 one of its key
purposes was to abolish the requirement for applicants to demonstrate a ‘need’
for new retail floorspace.
The abolition of this test was in
response to criticism in the Barker Report that singled the need test out as a
blunt and dysfunctional tool that, as the Government acknowledged, all too
often causes
planners to get caught up in debate about technical definitions, and overlook
the vital question of what the proposed development actually means for the town
centre and the people who rely on it.
Three years on, and PPS4 has been
superseded by the NPPF that makes absolutely no reference to a requirement for
applicants to demonstrate a ‘need’ for new proposals.
Yet, in a number of recent retail appeal
decisions the need test gained as much consideration as the sequential test and
impact. So are Inspectors and retail
planning boffins ignoring the guidance and giving life support to a hypothetical
and pretty meaningless test that ought to have been lain to rest three years
ago? It certainly seems so on the face
of it.
So why has the need test continued to
appear in retail planning cases? The
first reason appears to be that PPS4 was drafted so badly that need appeared, albeit
obliquely, as one of the strands (16.1.d) of the impact test.
It referred to impact “..taking account of current and future consumer expenditure capacity
in the catchment area up to five years from the time the application is made…”
If it were limited to this reference alone,
then one would have expected the need test to be confined to a few lines at the
end of the impact chapter in current retail assessments and appeal decisions.
What appears to have occurred however is
that in seeking to provide ‘Practice Guidance’ on PPS4, Sir Humphrey has opted
to insert the need test liberally and randomly throughout the document.
For example, at Paragraph 5.7 in the
context of the sequential test it refers to the prospect of opportunities
coming forward “likely to be capable of
meeting the same requirements as the application is intended to meet.” Sounds like a need test to me.
At Paragraph 6.33 in the context of the
sequential test it is somewhat more explicit:
“While
there is no policy requirement to demonstrate need, an operator claiming that
it is able to be flexible about its chosen business model would be expected to
demonstrated (sic) why a smaller store or stores could not meet a similar
need.”
Sir Humphrey has done well with this
one. In the same sentence he has claimed
there to be no policy requirement for a need test at the same time as
insisting that one would be necessary to support a new retail proposal.
He has also managed to sneak the dreaded need word into Paragraphs 7.34-7.36 in the context of assessing the appropriate
scale of new proposals.
Indeed, the only reference in the Practice
Guidance that appears to be properly reflective of the actual Guidance itself
is hidden away in the appendices at Paragraph D12, which suggests that turnover
ought to be considered:
“in
light of of quantitative capacity and other qualitative need considerations.”
As I have noted, the NPPF has superseded
PPS4 and is completely silent on need.
This has however proven no obstacle to Sir
Humphrey. Immediately following
publication of the NPPF his flunkies at DCLG asserted that the Practice
Guidance is still a material consideration in the determination of retail
planning applications.
The NPPF and the Practice Guidance make for
unlikely bedfellows. What we have is on one
hand a national policy framework in England built on principles of simplicity
and supporting development and on the other an ‘adopted’ Practice Guidance that
continues to advocate a test that contributes towards a confused, dysfunctional
and perhaps even anti-development approach towards new retail.
The result is confusion, with neither
practitioners nor local authorities understanding fully whether to consider,
and what weight to place upon, a demonstration of need.
One would have hoped that the egregious, plain
speaking Mr Pickles would have stepped in and addressed this
inconsistency. Perhaps he hasn’t seen
the need.